Відео

I'm not a lawyer, but I did study copyright law a bit for my masters in arts admin. I'm sorry to say, this does not match my understanding of fair use. You do not need a strong narrative reason for including copyright protected material. It just needs to be transformative. The problem, as others have mentioned, is that our legal system is structured to benefit the giant multi-national corporations that have consolidated huge swaths of pop culture IP. Film makers don't avoid using copyright protected IP in their films because it's illegal. They avoid it because they could get sued by a giant IP troll and run out of money before they were able to prove what they did was legal. It's never a question of what is legal. It's always a question of how much risk you are willing to take on.

Amazing, amazing video. Thank you for this. But whoa whoa whoa, let's pump the brakes on harsh Ready Player One critiques as that movie is lowkey about Spielberg coming to grips with his immeasurable impact on pop culture using IPs he was around for the creation of. Sort of like a S-tier studio-backed fair use movie

I live Nirvanna The Band The Show! They both did a good (and funny) video on how they used copyright during the shows production ua-cam.com/video/FQXxw6PUu_4/v-deo.htmlsi=FHytBT5CcXpMmD7S

I LOVE Matt Johnson, he’s actually a genius.

matt johnson is the director too??

When they take a foreign movie and try to make a remake they just always forget that the charm of the initial culture and the authenticity of their vision were the things that gave the movie that unique aura in the first place. Trying to make the same movie in that beaten Hollywood pattern just can't deliver the same experience

How can u not recommend Blade or The Incredible Hulk!?

In regards to The Punisher (1989), Louis Gossett Jr is always the best part of a movie. Edit: Nicholas Hammond... Act like Luke Skywalker, look like Tucker Carlson, and some how thats Peter Parker!? Doesnt help that he looks 40 years old lol

“Thor WONT sell WEED in IDAHO” 😂

0:20 that is not virtua fighter how could you even think thats virtua fighter

Be really careful with using fair use. It’s a defense. It doesn’t allow you to just do whatever you want. Chris Perez is one of the leading and practicing attorneys on copyright fair use. If you’re interested in working with them, their firm is called Kallif, Donaldson, and Perez.

Controversial opinion but media like movies should have the creative freedom to do whatever the fuck they want as long as it's not hurting anyone, and some logo or symbol or item or whatever of some known IP is braindead

Here at 54,372 views.

OMG OMG OMG! I have watched this video on UA-cam with G SMOKE 🐐🚬0⃣3⃣😜🖕 and Black Peter Griffin and it was awesome! I love Blackberry, Indiana Jones, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers, Ready Player One and Clueless! I also love the Space Jam: A New Legacy scenes! I enjoyed copyright loophole shit! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

thank u for all the recommendations, input & correlations - cheers mate!

How does this apply to unauthorized biographies. If I wanted to make a docu-drama about Captain Kangaroo… what can I get away with using? People publish unauthorized biographies all the time. I just don’t know the limits.

Dude, your video analysis was outstanding! I just used it to persuade a friend on watching the show. An evangelism of some sort, maybe(? Hugs from Portugal.

Where to watch if anyone could help?

yo wtf, alex? i'd certainly not intended to watch the entire thing. understated yet punishing delivery of some of the crispiest takes i've heard in a while.

I think this same stuff used in Slumdog Millionaire

But why does messing with film speed make scenes feel way they do?

*movie about the first USA smartphone, eg: Nokia (Finland) had been producing their "Communicator" line since the mid-1990s.

And you have to rely on a boomer judge that may or may not have access to Disney's secret pedo club. It worked for BlackBerry because no one cares about Tim Curry's performance in C&C, despite it ot being better tuan anything Disney has produced in the last ten years. (Yes: End Game)

Like the meme says “it’s free real estate”

The double take i just did on that thumbnail after reading the title 🤣🤣

5:41 anyone have a link for this interview?

I like the cheap John McEnroe costume

I think something very important has been left out, which is why most movies don't take advantage of this: it's meant for educational works only. The "transformative" and "integral to the story" parts of the requirements are referring to works communicating a specific piece of information or history in which said copyrighted works absolutely have to be mentioned in order to explain said information or event. The movies mentioned in the video are documentaries or at least dramatization/fictionizations of real events. Any form of fiction that isn't based strictly around a real person/event is practically incapable of using fair use for the simple fact that how integral something is to the work is up to the author, and since it isn't real or based on anything real, the court, and whoever is the proper owner, can argue that it isn't integral and you can simply write it out. And as plenty of other comments have already stated, fair use isn't a guarantee, and depends on the court's interpretation. Yeah its a long paragraph... I liked this video, it explained everything quite well (and in a short concise amount of time).But I think it failed to explain exactly why fair use isn't used more, which is something I think should have been brought up. TL;DR: Most movies don't use fair use because fair use is meant primarily for a specific category of movie, and in many instances fair use isn't even guaranteed to work.

The blackberry wasn’t the first smartphone was made by ibm not blackberry

The moment a lawyer is needed as an extra consultant the costs go up fast. People use non brands for cost effective reasons the vast majority of the time. But I agree ... It's a tool that is there, it should be utilized more :)

The problem is, none of this guarantees the filmmakers stay out of court. Even if your fair use case is rock solid, any one of those IP holders can still decide to take you to court. And if their pockets are deeper than yours they could easily crush you financially while still losing the case.

THIS is how you gain a new subscriber very fast. Great video!

I really wanna see a Pinocchio movie where instead of pleasant island, it’s the pleasant casino, which is pretty self explanatory

How does the fair use apply with things like Pepsi bottles on tables etc. That's the common issue I see is daily beverages and items we use.

Do we really? Do we really need to ask why?

1 ok now i need to watch this movie and 2 I never thought of movies using fair use. I've seen tv use this in the form of references, sometimes they show a clip of a movie in a show, or have the audio playing in the background or something. But this is a whole different story!

this is one of those videos you watch and think about not only in context with the art discussed, but also the culture of loving it as well. amazing work. first video from you i have seen but i am excited to binge the rest of your stuff and to see what you put out in the future. amazing amazing work.

great choices for talking about video essayists honestly

9:42 to be fair he WAS a dad

Hi Mr. Boucher, your about page said, "On a mission to watch every movie." I like your ambition and was wondering are you financially free and living on passive income to do this, perhaps have no kids, no obligation/responsibility, perhaps in a flexible relationship where you have time freedom to be able to do this? I ask because I too want to do this.

2:58 What is the name of this movie with the Asian woman?

The 1972 version is the most faithful to the original book.

Popeye was a Disney film.

The guy from Nirvanna the show the band made a movie?

What a great video essay. Not just a good example of how hard it is to translate animation to live-action, but a fun history lesson on the medium of animation itself. I gotta watch me some Popeye cartoons, I never knew how expressive and dynamic the animation was before.

Thanks for making this video. Great stuff, keep it up!

holy moly, straight to the point wth xD good video!!!

Amelie is a masterpiece. 'Nuff said.

Companys can still sue you though, or threaten to do so, and you will never have enough money to argue that what you did is fair use. It's completely useless. The argument at the end makes no sense. Fair use doesn't force filmmakers to make interesting art, the threat of violence copyright law poses didn't make the movie good, the commentary on culture and authentic depiction of it did. We would have more of these stories if you didn't have to write them with a lawyer or fear being sued for millions and having your life ruined. Copyright is the enemy of art and must go, culture belongs to all of us, not a few billionaires.

lol you put the virtua fighter logo over martial masters gameplay